Thursday, June 07, 2007

This "A" Has Gone Straight To My Head

From How Good People Make Tough Choices, by Rushworth M. Kidder

The impulse to condemn the ethical present...has always been there, as has the longing for the return to whatever will give us goodness. That perpetual impulse however, should not blind us to the quantitative and qualititative differences between our past and present technologies. Was there a system in Wordsworth's age that, if you could have turned it over to two engineers like those at Reactor Number Four and said, "Do the most unconscionable thing you can imagine," would have produced a Chernobyl? Where in the nineteenth century (to change the example) could you have found a ship large enough to load with some toxic substance, put a drunken captain in charge, and run it aground in Prince William Sound in Alaska to have done the damage caused by the Exxon Valdez oil spill on March 24, 1989?

...What's new, then, is not simply our knowledge. It's the sheer scale and power of our systems--scientific, technological, financial, governmental, educational, and so forth. ...Like megaphones, they amplify small whispers of wrongdoing into vast bellows of amorality. In that megaphone effect, a single moral lapse--a single ethical Chernobyl--can now affect millions for centuries. ...[This power] now lies in the hands of more-or-les well-meaning experts--whose only failings, perhaps, are a fuzziness at the moral core and a consequent limiting of the vision. The danger increasingly lies in the hands of otherwise ordinary people--people you and I know and like. They are not willfully setting out to create the next Chernobyl. Yet they may be operating in a systemic and personal ethical vacuum that, in the end, leaves them unable to tell right from wrong...the are walking straight into a world-class moral temptation.

In my opinion, this is why getting education right is crucial and a moral imparative. What do you think?

6 Comments:

Blogger SkylersDad said...

Not that we need a better reason to put more emphasis on educating our young, but this is as good a reason as I have heard.

As a veteran of the cold war, I really have no idea how we made it through without a major confrontation.

Thursday, June 07, 2007 1:58:00 PM

 
Blogger vikkitikkitavi said...

If we really gave a shit about education, we would equalize education dollars, and stop tying funding to local property taxes.

But wealthier people will never let that happen. Because they will not allow their own children to "suffer" to increase the benefit to poorer children.

The end.

Thursday, June 07, 2007 4:11:00 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

maybe we could have American Idol stars recite the Gettysburg Address or the times tables??

the OTHER problem is that chaos is easy; REEEAAAL easy. Just go to the grocery store and walk down the wine aisle. then, at total random, begin throwing wine bottles every which-a-way and scream obscenities at the top of your vox. There, in less than 10 seconds you've created a mess that will take someone 2 hours to clean up.

Easy. Make it LESS easy and maybe y'all got something.

Thursday, June 07, 2007 4:43:00 PM

 
Blogger Phil said...

I might argue that in 15th century three large boats, (the Nina, the Pinta and the Santa Maria) and a drunk captain (Columbus) did deliver a load of toxic substance (small-pox among other things) and created a disaster (the genocide of the native population of North America) much larger than Chernobyl or Exxon Valdez.

Is education a tool to prevent such things? I'm not sure, but it sure as shit couldn't hurt.

Thursday, June 07, 2007 7:06:00 PM

 
Blogger Doc said...

Amen Phil. Amen.

Doc

Friday, June 08, 2007 2:36:00 PM

 
Blogger don'tneedtoknow said...

I'm with Vikki.

Saturday, June 09, 2007 2:58:00 PM

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home